MSNLGA

Madison to New York

Direct and one-stop flights from Dane County Regional Truax Field (MSN) to LaGuardia Airport (LGA), ranked by how reliably they actually get you there.

Latest official data runs to 30 September 2026. Government on-time statistics are published several weeks after the month ends, so this page shows the past 3 months. Live tracking fills in recent days as it builds up.

Our recommendation

Book Republic Airways YX5664

Direct2h 20m journeyDeparts 07:00, arrives 10:20
8.3Verdict
  • 91% reached New York on time, the best record on this route
  • Direct, so there's no connection to miss

Book Republic Airways YX5664 (direct). Over this period it reached New York on time 91% of the time, with a typical journey of 2h 20m. If speed matters most, Republic Airways YX5847 (direct) is the quickest at 2h 17m.

Know your rights. US DOT passenger rights covers this trip: US law does not require airlines to pay compensation for delays or cancellations. What you can claim

  • This pick is based on 23 journeys, so treat it as an early signal.

Prices are shown for convenience and never affect our recommendation. How we pick

Flexible on dates?

Pick a range of up to 14 days and we'll tell you the best day to fly, and the most reliable journey that actually operates on each date.

Every way to fly Madison to New York

Past 3 months. Direct flights and one-stop journeys, ranked by how reliably they actually got passengers there. A journey is on time if it reached New York within 15 minutes of schedule; a missed connection counts as late.

Live prices aren't connected in this preview yet. When they are, each journey shows its lowest current fare for the date you pick. Prices never affect our recommendation.

  1. Recommended
    07:00 MSN10:20 LGARepublic Airways YX5664
    Journey
    2h 20m
    Arrived on time
    91%
    Flies
    Daily
    Price, Fri 20 Nov
    —
    Passengers
    —
    Verdict
    8.3

    Based on 23 journeys; it actually took 2h 09m on average.

  2. Fastest
    07:00 MSN10:17 LGARepublic Airways YX5847
    Journey
    2h 17m
    Arrived on time
    86%
    Flies
    Daily
    Price, Fri 20 Nov
    —
    Passengers
    —
    Verdict
    7.9

    Based on 22 journeys; it actually took 2h 21m on average; 1 cancelled.

  3. 15:35 MSN18:59 LGARepublic Airways YX5850
    Journey
    2h 24m
    Arrived on time
    80%
    Flies
    Sun, Mon, Tue, Wed, Thu, Fri
    Price, Fri 20 Nov
    —
    Passengers
    —
    Verdict
    7.2

    Based on 20 journeys; it actually took 2h 26m on average.

  4. 07:00 MSN10:25 LGARepublic Airways YX4490
    Journey
    2h 24m
    Arrived on time
    77%
    Flies
    Daily
    Price, Fri 20 Nov
    —
    Passengers
    —
    Verdict
    7.0

    Based on 22 journeys; it actually took 2h 15m on average; 1 cancelled.

  5. 08:05 MSN11:29 LGARepublic Airways YX4624
    Journey
    2h 24m
    Arrived on time
    74%
    Flies
    Daily
    Price, Fri 20 Nov
    —
    Passengers
    —
    Verdict
    6.8

    Based on 23 journeys; it actually took 2h 18m on average; 2 cancelled.

  6. 15:08 MSN18:30 LGAEndeavor Air 9E5033
    Journey
    2h 26m
    Arrived on time
    65%
    Flies
    Sun, Mon, Tue, Wed, Thu, Fri
    Price, Fri 20 Nov
    —
    Passengers
    —
    Verdict
    5.9

    Based on 17 journeys; it actually took 2h 26m on average; 3 cancelled.

  7. 16:12 MSN19:30 LGADelta Air Lines DL8819
    Journey
    2h 18m
    Arrived on time
    50%
    Flies
    Wed, Thu
    Price, Fri 20 Nov
    —
    Passengers
    —
    Verdict
    Not enough history

    Based on 2 journeys; it actually took 3h 41m on average.

Direct flights by airline

Past 3 months. A flight is late if it arrives more than 15 minutes after schedule; cancellations count against the airline.
RankAirlineVerdictOn timeLateCancelledTypical delay when latePassengersCrew service
1Republic Airways
YX4490, YX4591, YX4624, YX5664, YX5847, YX5850 · also sold as AA4490, AA4591, AA4624, DL5664, DL5847, DL5850
8.1
81%
15 of 10041h 00mNo ratings yet—
2Endeavor Air
9E5033 · also sold as DL5033
6.2
62%
3 of 1321h 37mNo ratings yet—
Delta Air Lines
DL8819
No score yet
—
———No ratings yet—

On-time record over time

  • Endeavor Air
  • Republic Airways
100%80%60%40%20%17 Aug31 Aug14 Sept28 SeptEndeavor AirRepublic Airways
Show as a table
Week ofEndeavor AirRepublic Airways
17 Aug100% (1)100% (4)
24 Aug66.7% (6)71.4% (14)
31 Aug40% (5)71.4% (14)
7 Sept100% (1)89.5% (19)
14 Sept—80% (20)
21 Sept—80% (20)
28 Sept—88.9% (9)

Questions travellers ask

What's the best way to fly from Madison to New York?

Book Republic Airways YX5664 (direct). Over this period it reached New York on time 91% of the time, with a typical journey of 2h 20m. If speed matters most, Republic Airways YX5847 (direct) is the quickest at 2h 17m.

Which airline is most on time from Madison to New York?

Over the past 3 months, Republic Airways had the best record on this route, arriving on time on 81% of 100 flights.

Which airlines fly direct from Madison to New York?

Republic Airways (YX4490, YX4591, YX4624, YX5664, YX5847, YX5850), Endeavor Air (9E5033), Delta Air Lines (DL8819).

How often are Endeavor Air flights from Madison to New York late?

3 of 13 flights arrived more than 15 minutes late over the past 3 months. When late, the typical delay was 1h 37m.