CommutAir vs Republic Airways

CommutAir comes out ahead, with a Verdict Score of 9.0 against 7.7 and 13 points more flights on time (90% vs 77%).

CommutAir and Republic Airways compared
MeasureCommutAirRepublic Airways
Verdict Score9.0 (better)7.7
Arrived on time90% (better)77%
Late flights10% (better)20%
Cancelled0.3% (better)3.2%
Typical delay when late1h 21m1h 16m (better)
Passenger rating——
Cabin crew service——
Comfort——
Value for money——

Past 3 months for flight data; passenger ratings cover the past 12 months. The better figure in each row is marked.

On the routes they both fly

On-time record on shared routes
RouteCommutAir on timeRepublic Airways on time
Dulles to State College90% of 122100% of 2
State College to Dulles93% of 121100% of 2
Dulles to Syracuse77% of 6091% of 21
Syracuse to Dulles82% of 6295% of 20
Burlington to Dulles82% of 2888% of 76
Dulles to Pittsburgh94% of 1773% of 78
Pittsburgh to Dulles94% of 1782% of 78
Buffalo to Dulles80% of 4494% of 16
Dulles to Buffalo82% of 4494% of 16
Dulles to Burlington82% of 2876% of 37
Greenville/Greer/Spartanburg to Dulles86% of 43100% of 1
Dulles to Greenville/Greer/Spartanburg88% of 430% of 1
Dulles to Greensboro82% of 44100% of 1
Cincinnati / Covington to Dulles68% of 22100% of 1
Dulles to Detroit36% of 1185% of 40
Detroit to Dulles46% of 1193% of 41
Dulles to Cincinnati / Covington86% of 22100% of 1
Dulles to Charleston— of 071% of 14
Charleston to Dulles— of 092% of 13
Rochester to Dulles65% of 20— of 0
Dulles to Rochester74% of 19— of 0
Columbus to Dulles0% of 195% of 41
Dulles to Columbus100% of 178% of 40
Norfolk to Dulles55% of 11100% of 3
Dulles to Norfolk82% of 11100% of 3
Providence/Warwick to Dulles100% of 5100% of 1
Dulles to Providence/Warwick100% of 5100% of 1
Hartford to Dulles100% of 586% of 7
Dulles to Hartford100% of 586% of 7

Questions travellers ask

Which is better, CommutAir or Republic Airways?

CommutAir comes out ahead, with a Verdict Score of 9.0 against 7.7 and 13 points more flights on time (90% vs 77%).

Is CommutAir more punctual than Republic Airways?

Over the past 3 months, CommutAir arrived on time on 90% of 7463 tracked flights and Republic Airways on 77% of 38475.

CommutAir vs Republic Airways: which airline is more reliable? | FlyVerdict