CommutAir vs Mesa Airlines

CommutAir comes out ahead, with a Verdict Score of 9.0 against 8.7 and 3 points more flights on time (90% vs 87%).

CommutAir and Mesa Airlines compared
MeasureCommutAirMesa Airlines
Verdict Score9.0 (better)8.7
Arrived on time90% (better)87%
Late flights10% (better)13%
Cancelled0.3% (better)0.3%
Typical delay when late1h 21m1h 19m (better)
Passenger rating——
Cabin crew service——
Comfort——
Value for money——

Past 3 months for flight data; passenger ratings cover the past 12 months. The better figure in each row is marked.

On the routes they both fly

On-time record on shared routes
RouteCommutAir on timeMesa Airlines on time
Houston to El Paso89% of 4489% of 161
El Paso to Houston82% of 4491% of 161
Houston to Oklahoma City100% of 993% of 198
Midland to Houston100% of 494% of 175
Houston to Midland100% of 394% of 176
Oklahoma City to Houston100% of 995% of 197
Houston to Lafayette91% of 12589% of 73
Lafayette to Houston95% of 12792% of 72
Corpus Christi to Houston93% of 11887% of 37
Houston to Corpus Christi94% of 11983% of 36
Baton Rouge to Houston91% of 12690% of 29
Houston to Baton Rouge93% of 12583% of 29
Mobile to Houston95% of 153100% of 5
Houston to Mobile89% of 150100% of 7
Birmingham to Houston96% of 4889% of 89
Houston to Birmingham83% of 4890% of 87
Dulles to Knoxville/Maryville83% of 10893% of 40
Knoxville/Maryville to Dulles94% of 10892% of 39
Houston to Lubbock93% of 14089% of 9
Lubbock to Houston94% of 14063% of 8
Syracuse to Dulles83% of 6488% of 75
Dulles to Syracuse76% of 6278% of 76
Houston to McAllen96% of 6789% of 46
McAllen to Houston97% of 6687% of 45
Houston to Harlingen94% of 108100% of 2
Harlingen to Houston95% of 107100% of 1
Houston to Knoxville/Maryville— of 090% of 111
Panama City Beach to Houston90% of 86100% of 2
Tulsa to Houston100% of 292% of 84
Houston to Panama City Beach93% of 8567% of 3

Questions travellers ask

Which is better, CommutAir or Mesa Airlines?

CommutAir comes out ahead, with a Verdict Score of 9.0 against 8.7 and 3 points more flights on time (90% vs 87%).

Is CommutAir more punctual than Mesa Airlines?

Over the past 3 months, CommutAir arrived on time on 90% of 7655 tracked flights and Mesa Airlines on 87% of 8164.

CommutAir vs Mesa Airlines: which airline is more reliable? | FlyVerdict