American Airlines vs Frontier Airlines

American Airlines and Frontier Airlines are too close to call: their Verdict Scores are within 0 points.

American Airlines and Frontier Airlines compared
MeasureAmerican AirlinesFrontier Airlines
Verdict Score7.47.4
Arrived on time74%74% (better)
Late flights25%25% (better)
Cancelled0.9% (better)0.9%
Typical delay when late1h 27m (better)1h 36m
Passenger rating——
Cabin crew service——
Comfort——
Value for money——

Past 3 months for flight data; passenger ratings cover the past 12 months. The better figure in each row is marked.

On the routes they both fly

On-time record on shared routes
RouteAmerican Airlines on timeFrontier Airlines on time
Dallas-Fort Worth to Los Angeles73% of 49487% of 89
Los Angeles to Dallas-Fort Worth86% of 49080% of 89
Chicago to Dallas-Fort Worth65% of 52980% of 66
Dallas-Fort Worth to Chicago74% of 53269% of 65
Dallas-Fort Worth to Phoenix72% of 44783% of 78
Phoenix to Dallas-Fort Worth86% of 43381% of 77
Dallas-Fort Worth to Las Vegas69% of 44479% of 144
Las Vegas to Dallas-Fort Worth79% of 44171% of 143
New York to Dallas-Fort Worth73% of 49754% of 41
Dallas-Fort Worth to New York64% of 49461% of 41
Dallas-Fort Worth to Miami66% of 47571% of 45
Miami to Dallas-Fort Worth74% of 46980% of 45
Dallas-Fort Worth to Orlando65% of 35881% of 115
Charlotte to Orlando70% of 38470% of 103
Philadelphia to Orlando77% of 30172% of 198
Orlando to Philadelphia80% of 30171% of 198
Orlando to Charlotte79% of 38083% of 101
Orlando to Dallas-Fort Worth76% of 35180% of 112
Denver to Dallas-Fort Worth70% of 33975% of 145
Dallas-Fort Worth to Denver58% of 33678% of 145
Charlotte to Dallas-Fort Worth80% of 41875% of 47
Dallas-Fort Worth to Charlotte76% of 41785% of 47
Chicago to Los Angeles62% of 41067% of 18
Los Angeles to Chicago81% of 40294% of 18
Chicago to Philadelphia64% of 40671% of 24
Philadelphia to Chicago72% of 40063% of 24
Dallas-Fort Worth to San Francisco60% of 35667% of 49
Dallas-Fort Worth to Philadelphia75% of 35673% of 41
San Francisco to Dallas-Fort Worth74% of 35685% of 48
Philadelphia to Dallas-Fort Worth81% of 34190% of 40

Questions travellers ask

Which is better, American Airlines or Frontier Airlines?

American Airlines and Frontier Airlines are too close to call: their Verdict Scores are within 0 points.

Is American Airlines more punctual than Frontier Airlines?

Over the past 3 months, American Airlines arrived on time on 74% of 110800 tracked flights and Frontier Airlines on 74% of 24759.