American Airlines vs Envoy Air

Envoy Air comes out ahead, with a Verdict Score of 8.1 against 7.4 and 6 points more flights on time (81% vs 74%).

American Airlines and Envoy Air compared
MeasureAmerican AirlinesEnvoy Air
Verdict Score7.48.1 (better)
Arrived on time74%81% (better)
Late flights25%18% (better)
Cancelled0.9% (better)1.0%
Typical delay when late1h 27m1h 17m (better)
Passenger rating——
Cabin crew service——
Comfort——
Value for money——

Past 3 months for flight data; passenger ratings cover the past 12 months. The better figure in each row is marked.

On the routes they both fly

On-time record on shared routes
RouteAmerican Airlines on timeEnvoy Air on time
Chicago to Dallas-Fort Worth65% of 52865% of 40
Dallas-Fort Worth to Chicago75% of 53169% of 39
Dallas-Fort Worth to San Antonio63% of 42082% of 92
San Antonio to Dallas-Fort Worth80% of 39776% of 92
Dallas-Fort Worth to Austin62% of 44066% of 77
Austin to Dallas-Fort Worth73% of 44262% of 77
Nashville to Dallas-Fort Worth80% of 379— of 0
Dallas-Fort Worth to Nashville71% of 376— of 0
Chicago to Boston53% of 37288% of 17
Boston to Chicago67% of 37282% of 17
Dallas-Fort Worth to Fayetteville/Springdale/Rogers52% of 13287% of 251
Washington to Dallas-Fort Worth84% of 3620% of 1
Fayetteville/Springdale/Rogers to Dallas-Fort Worth70% of 11687% of 251
Dallas-Fort Worth to Springfield89% of 1884% of 347
Washington to Chicago68% of 397100% of 1
Houston to Dallas-Fort Worth76% of 27585% of 47
Dallas-Fort Worth to Houston62% of 27094% of 47
Dallas-Fort Worth to Oklahoma City61% of 26487% of 60
Oklahoma City to Dallas-Fort Worth75% of 25175% of 61
Dallas-Fort Worth to Corpus Christi73% of 1583% of 282
Atlanta to Dallas-Fort Worth75% of 272— of 0
Dallas-Fort Worth to Atlanta68% of 273— of 0
Dallas-Fort Worth to Albuquerque58% of 17783% of 116
Dallas-Fort Worth to El Paso63% of 26284% of 31
El Paso to Dallas-Fort Worth82% of 26377% of 30
Albuquerque to Dallas-Fort Worth86% of 17779% of 116
Dallas-Fort Worth to Kansas City72% of 26794% of 49
Dallas-Fort Worth to New Orleans62% of 25579% of 24
Dallas-Fort Worth to McAllen67% of 18188% of 112
Dallas-Fort Worth to Tulsa66% of 22190% of 76

Questions travellers ask

Which is better, American Airlines or Envoy Air?

Envoy Air comes out ahead, with a Verdict Score of 8.1 against 7.4 and 6 points more flights on time (81% vs 74%).

Is American Airlines more punctual than Envoy Air?

Over the past 3 months, American Airlines arrived on time on 74% of 111766 tracked flights and Envoy Air on 81% of 36584.