Alitalia vs Lufthansa

Lufthansa comes out ahead, with a Verdict Score of 8.6 against 7.0 and 16 points more flights on time (86% vs 70%).

Alitalia and Lufthansa compared
MeasureAlitaliaLufthansa
Verdict Score7.08.6 (better)
Arrived on time70%86% (better)
Late flights30%14% (better)
Cancelled0.4%0.2% (better)
Typical delay when late46 min36 min (better)
Passenger rating——
Cabin crew service——
Comfort——
Value for money——

Past 3 months for flight data; passenger ratings cover the past 12 months. The better figure in each row is marked.

On the routes they both fly

On-time record on shared routes
RouteAlitalia on timeLufthansa on time
Rome to Munich100% of 286% of 7
Munich to Rome100% of 271% of 7
Frankfurt am Main to Rome100% of 171% of 7
Rome to Frankfurt am Main50% of 260% of 5
Munich to Segrate100% of 1100% of 4

Questions travellers ask

Which is better, Alitalia or Lufthansa?

Lufthansa comes out ahead, with a Verdict Score of 8.6 against 7.0 and 16 points more flights on time (86% vs 70%).

Is Alitalia more punctual than Lufthansa?

Over the past 3 months, Alitalia arrived on time on 70% of 233 tracked flights and Lufthansa on 86% of 1125.

Alitalia vs Lufthansa: which airline is more reliable? | FlyVerdict